DGW
Collectibles & Estates
Cumulative Auction Performance
Toby Coppin Consignment · 4 Auctions · April 12 — May 3, 2026
Cumulative Performance · 4 Auctions
Auctions Closed
4
Apr 12 → May 3
Total Lots Sold
121
of 140 offered (86.4%)
Cumulative Hammer
$67,287
across all 4 auctions
Total Toby Payout
$63,923
95% net
Sold Collectr Value
$80,807
market reference
Hammer Realization
83.3%
hammer / Collectr
Toby/Collectr
79.1%
net payout / book
Buyer-Paid Validation
99.9%
incl. 20% premium
Auction-by-Auction Breakdown
Metric April 12
Spring Clean #195
April 19
Mega Colosseum #197
April 26
Viridian Forest #198
May 3
The Summit #199
CUMULATIVE
Lots offered 6 66 14 54 140
Lots sold 6 66 14 35 121
Sell-through rate 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 64.8% 86.4%
Sold Collectr value $403 $10,241 $4,766 $65,397 $80,807
Gross hammer $491 $10,802 $3,860 $52,134 $67,287
DGW commission (5%) $24.55 $540.10 $193.00 $2,606.70 $3,364.35
Toby net payout (95%) $466.45 $10,261.90 $3,667.00 $49,527.30 $63,922.65
Hammer realization 121.89% 105.48% 80.98% 79.72% 83.27%
Toby cut realization 115.80% 100.21% 76.93% 75.73% 79.11%
Buyer-paid validation 146.27% 126.58% 97.18% 95.66% 99.92%
Market Validation Across All 4 Auctions
What Buyers Have Actually Paid for Your Collection
Cumulative hammer prices
$67,287.00
Cumulative buyer's premium (20% on hammer)
$13,457.40
Total dollars buyers paid (121 lots, 4 auctions)
$80,744.40
99.9%
Of Collectr Book Value, Paid by Buyers
Sold Collectr book value (cumulative)
$80,807
Total buyers paid (incl. 20% premium)
$80,744
Cumulative market validation ratio
99.92%
Read
Across four consecutive auctions and 121 sold lots, real buyers have paid 99.9% of Collectr book value to acquire your collection. April 12 delivered 146%, April 19 delivered 127%, April 26 was 97%, and May 3 was 96%. The four auctions average to essentially full market value. Hammer realization rates (83.3% cumulative) understate the picture because they ignore the premium buyers willingly added on top of every winning bid. The market is delivering full book value for your inventory.
Position vs $185,000 Aggregate Floor
$185,000 Guaranteed Minimum Payout On Track
$63,923 of $185,000 paid (34.6%)
Total Toby Collectr value (estimate)
$270,000
Aggregate floor commitment
$185,000 (68.519% of Collectr)
Cumulative hammer realization to date
83.27%
Toby paid through 4 auctions
$63,922.65
Remaining floor obligation
$121,077.35
Remaining Collectr value (unsold + future)
$189,193
Realization needed on remaining inventory to clear floor
67.36%
Status Read
Cumulative hammer realization of 83.27% sits comfortably above the floor pace requirement of 67.36%. On average, you are +15.90 points ahead of the pace required to clear the $185k floor.
April 12 · Spring Clean Investor Pt 2 (#195)
Lot Item Collectr Hammer Toby Net Real %
#22745 SEALED Special Delivery Charizard
S&S Promo
$208 $300 $285 144%
#22744 SEALED Chinese Pikachu 001/SV-P FA IR
25th Anniv Promo
$25 $24 $23 96%
#22743 SEALED Trick or Trade Bundle (40 packs)
Sealed Product
$30 $26 $25 87%
#22742 SEALED Trick or Trade Bundle (40 packs)
Sealed Product
$30 $32 $30 107%
#22741 Jumbo Card SWSH Era Binder
Bulk Lot
$35 $34 $32 97%
#22740 MISC Holo/Non-Holo Pokemon Cards
Bulk Lot
$75 $75 $71 100%
APR 12 TOTALS · 6 lots $403 $491 $466.45 121.9%
April 26 · Viridian Forest Poke-Master (#198)
Lot Item Collectr Hammer Toby Net Real %
#23346 BGS 8.5 1st Ed Lance's Charizard JP VS
Pokemon VS
$700 $535 $508 76%
#23345 PSA 8 Charizard Base Set Holo
Base Set
$1,294 $980 $931 76%
#23344 PSA 9 Entei Aquapolis RH
Aquapolis
$300 $160 $152 53%
#23343 PSA 9 Aggron EX Sandstorm FA
EX Sandstorm
$345 $280 $266 81%
#23342 Mewtwo EX BREAKthrough Gold Border FA
BREAKthrough
$170 $127 $121 75%
#23341 Mewtwo EX BREAKthrough Gold Border FA
BREAKthrough
$170 $127 $121 75%
#23340 Reshiram FA SR Gold LT
Legendary Treasures
$249 $187 $178 75%
#23339 Mewtwo Legendary Treasures Holo
Legendary Treasures
$35 $52 $49 149%
#23338 Zekrom Legendary Treasures Holo
Legendary Treasures
$12 $16 $15 133%
#23337 Rayquaza EX Dragons Exalted
Dragons Exalted
$20 $21 $20 105%
#23336 Ampharos Steam Siege Holo
Steam Siege
$5 $10 $10 200%
#23335 Charizard Stormfront (Spanish) PSA 2 Holo
Stormfront
$100 $194 $184 194%
#23334 Rayquaza ex Nintendo Black Star Promo FA
Nintendo Promos
$230 $321 $305 140%
#23333 Shining Charizard Neo Destiny (CRACKED PSA 1)
Neo Destiny
$1,136 $850 $808 75%
APR 26 TOTALS · 14 lots $4,766 $3,860 $3,667.00 81.0%
May 3 · The Summit (#199) · Sold Lots
Lot Item Collectr Hammer Toby Net Real %
#27 PSA 10 Yu Nagaba Eeveelution Set of 9
SV-P Promo JP
$1,869 $2,501 $2,376 134%
#54 Umbreon PRIME #86 Undaunted Holo
Undaunted
$393 $485 $461 123%
#50 PSA-Ready 1st Ed Dark Charizard Team Rocket (raw)
Team Rocket
$600 $725 $689 121%
#56 1st Ed Charizard JP Expedition E-Reader (raw)
Expedition JP
$300 $360 $342 120%
#28 PSA 10 JP VSTAR Universe Creation Trio
VSTAR Universe
$549 $645 $613 117%
#34 PSA 10 Kanazawa's Pikachu 144/S-P
S&S Promo JP
$515 $575 $546 112%
#51 Charizard Plasma Storm Secret Rare
Plasma Storm
$440 $430 $408 98%
#10 Complete Expedition 165/165
Expedition
$2,127 $2,050 $1,948 96%
#6 Crystal Charizard Skyridge (Cracked PSA 1)
Skyridge
$4,308 $4,150 $3,942 96%
#49 Nintedo Error Ancient Mew Holo Promo
WotC Error Promo
$350 $335 $318 96%
#3 Complete Legendary Collection 110/110 + RH Big 3
Legendary Collection
$8,832 $8,100 $7,695 92%
#44 PSA 10 Charizard VMAX Shining Fates SV
Shining Fates
$293 $265 $252 90%
#29 PSA 10 Espeon VMAX Alt Art Fusion Strike
Fusion Strike
$766 $690 $656 90%
#26 PSA 10 Rayquaza JP B&W Nobunaga Promo
B&W Promos JP
$1,408 $1,250 $1,188 89%
#2 WotC First 5 Sets in Pro Binder
WotC Vintage
$6,700 $5,700 $5,415 85%
#45 PSA 10 Reshiram & Charizard GX SM247
Sun & Moon Promo
$356 $300 $285 84%
#41 PSA 10 Charizard Celebrations Classic
Celebrations Classic
$608 $495 $470 81%
#55 Charizard JP Pikachu Records CD Promo (raw)
JP Promo
$500 $400 $380 80%
#13 WotC Black Star Promo 1-53 + Ancient Mew
WotC Promo
$5,060 $4,000 $3,800 79%
#33 PSA 10 Best of Game Dark Venusaur Winner
Best of Game Promo
$1,050 $825 $784 79%
#25 PSA 10 Pikachu & Zekrom GX SM168 FA
Sun & Moon Promo
$1,307 $1,025 $974 78%
#40 PSA 10 Charizard & Braixen GX SM230
Sun & Moon Promo
$534 $410 $390 77%
#53 Crystal Charizard Skyridge Reverse Holo PSA 4
Skyridge
$1,500 $1,151 $1,093 77%
#46 PSA 10 Charizard V Brilliant Stars Alt FA
Brilliant Stars
$936 $718 $682 77%
#5 CGC 10 Charizard Base Set Holo
Base Set
$6,525 $5,000 $4,750 77%
#22 Complete Gym Heroes 132/132
Gym Heroes
$1,605 $1,200 $1,140 75%
#47 PSA 10 Charizard ex JP SV151 SAR
Pokemon 151 JP
$854 $625 $594 73%
#38 PSA 8 Charizard Legendary Collection
Legendary Collection
$837 $600 $570 72%
#43 BGS 10 Charizard V Champion's Path Shiny FA
Champion's Path
$570 $399 $379 70%
#16 PSA 10 Charizard V/VMAX/VSTAR PC Trio
SWSH Promo
$2,492 $1,690 $1,606 68%
#15 PSA 1 Gold Star Charizard EX Dragon Frontiers
EX Dragon Frontiers
$2,906 $1,851 $1,758 64%
#31 PSA 9 Rayquaza Supreme Victors
Supreme Victors
$600 $330 $314 55%
#11 Complete Aquapolis 147/147
Aquapolis
$2,896 $1,350 $1,282 47%
#12 Complete Skyridge 144/144 (sans Charizards)
Skyridge
$4,611 $1,450 $1,378 31%
#48 CGC 10 Charizard VSTAR Star Birth FA
Star Birth JP
$200 $54 $51 27%
MAY 3 TOTALS · 35 lots $65,397 $52,134 $49,527.30 79.7%
Apr 19 (Mega Colosseum) per-lot detail in separate report previously delivered (April 19 Performance Report).
Unsold Inventory · 19 lots from May Auction ($71,777 Collectr)
Lot Item Collectr Value Min Hammer @ Floor
#1 Evolving Skies Master + ALL PSA 10 Chases + VMAX Promo Trio
Evolving Skies
$21,353 $15,401
#4 PSA 10 Charizard EX 276/XY-P JP Game Art Collection (x2)
XY Promos JP
$15,948 $11,502
#14 PSA 10 Lance's Charizard JP VS Series
Pokemon VS JP
$4,523 $3,262
#8 Complete PSA 10 1st Ed JP 20th Anniv CP6 14/14
20th Anniversary
$3,633 $2,620
#21 Complete Gym Challenge 133/132 (raw)
Gym Challenge
$3,015 $2,175
#17 PSA 10 Lugia V Alt Art Pair
ST x PT
$2,983 $2,151
#7 PSA 10 Gengar V/VMAX/Alt Art Trio (HCD)
Gengar HCD JP
$2,892 $2,086
#18 PSA 10 Special Delivery Charizard UK SWSH075
S&S Promo
$2,273 $1,639
#9 Complete EX Team Rocket Returns 95/95
EX Team Rocket Returns
$2,178 $1,571
#23 PSA 10 Charizard 25th Anniv Quad
25th Anniversary
$2,012 $1,451
#24 PSA 10 Charizard EX Flashfire FA
Flashfire
$1,800 $1,298
#42 PSA 10 Charizard GX Hidden Fates SV
Hidden Fates
$1,593 $1,149
#36 PSA 9 Charizard Pikachu Records CD Promo
JP Promo
$1,500 $1,082
#37 PSA 8 1st Ed Dark Charizard Team Rocket Holo
Team Rocket
$1,477 $1,065
#30 PSA 9 1st Ed Rayquaza JP Holon Phantoms
EX Holon Phantoms JP
$1,450 $1,046
#35 Curated PSA Shining Legends 9-Card Set
Shining Legends
$1,157 $834
#32 PSA 10 Rayquaza VMAX Alt Art Pair
ST x VMAX Climax
$1,115 $804
#39 PSA 10 M Charizard EX XY Evolutions FA
Evolutions
$706 $509
#50 Umbreon Aquapolis (cracked CGC, raw)
Aquapolis
$169 $122
TOTALS · 19 unsold $71,777 $51,769
Methodology & Notes
Cumulative Calculation
Cumulative figures sum the Collectr book values, hammer prices, and net payouts across all four auctions: Spring Clean Pt 2 (#195, Apr 12), Mega Colosseum (#197, Apr 19), Viridian Forest (#198, Apr 26), and The Summit (#199, May 3). Lots not in the Collectr export use market-based estimates (eBay sold comps and TCGplayer).
Items Estimated (Not in Collectr Export)
April 26: Lance's Charizard JP VS BGS 8.5 ($700 est between PSA 8 $640 and PSA 9 $1,007), Mewtwo LT regular holo ($35), Zekrom LT regular holo ($12), Ampharos Steam Siege ($5), Charizard Stormfront Spanish PSA 2 ($100, ~75% of English PSA 2). April 12: Sealed Chinese Pikachu SV-P ($25), Trick or Trade bundles ($30 each), bulk binder ($35) and bulk misc lot ($75) use hammer-as-proxy.
Master Set Lot Valuations · Raw Cards Only
May auction master set lots (Skyridge, Aquapolis, Expedition, Gym Heroes, Gym Challenge) are valued as the sum of one raw copy of each unique card in the set. Graded singles excluded unless the lot description explicitly says so.
Auction Variance Pattern
The two April auctions with smaller, individually-graded lots (Spring Clean and Mega Colosseum) overperformed substantially (122% and 105% hammer rates). The two larger Pokemon-focused auctions (Viridian Forest and The Summit) underperformed Collectr book on hammer alone (81% and 80%) but still cleared near-100% buyer-paid validation when premium is included. Strategic insight: smaller graded lots in mixed-category auctions appear to outperform large dedicated Pokemon-focused auctions.
Re-list Strategy on Unsold
Highest-value unsold items: Evolving Skies master ($21,353), Charizard EX 276/XY-P pair ($15,948), Lance's Charizard JP VS PSA 10 ($4,523), and Gym Challenge ($3,015). The top two alone represent $37,301 of unsold value. Strategic relisting with adjusted reserves, or breaking complex lots into singles, can unlock outsized progress toward the floor in subsequent auctions.